Hercules, Rewritten: What If It Was a Western?
From zero to hero, with spurs on.
Disney's Hercules (1997) is a blast: gospel-singing Muses, Danny DeVito as a grumpy satyr coach and James Woods's Hades as a fast-talking Hollywood agent from the underworld. But what if it were a Western?
Olympus is a frontier town
Olympus isn't a palace in the clouds. It's a dusty town in the Old West. Zeus is the old sheriff, run out of town years ago. And Hades? He owns the whole place.
Hercules is a farm kid with a secret
He grows up on a little farm, strong but clumsy, never knowing who his real father is. When Hades's gang drives his family off their land, Hercules sets out to find out who he really is.
Phil is a washed-up trainer
Phil used to train the greatest heroes of the West. They all let him down. Hercules is his last chance.
Hades is a cattle baron
Hades controls the land, the water and the railroad. Anyone who won't work for him gets run out of town. His enforcers are the Four Horsemen, but they're more bumbling than scary, like Pain and Panic in spurs.
Meg is a card sharp
Meg works for Hades, paying off an old debt. She's sharp, funny and not impressed by Hercules. At first.
The final act: high noon
Hercules rides into Olympus. Hades laughs: "You ain't nothing, boy." The whole town comes out to watch. Hercules uses his strength to protect the townsfolk, not to win. And when Hades's plan backfires, he ends up tumbling into his own mineshaft.
The ending
The town is free. Hercules tips his hat to Meg. And then, for once, he doesn't ride off alone. He stays.
What the original nails
Disney's Hercules is about what makes a true hero. Hercules thinks it's strength and fame. REAL: in the end, he becomes a god only by risking his life to save Meg. As Zeus tells him, a true hero is measured by his heart, not his muscles. And then he gives up immortality to stay with the people he loves.
What our version breaks
Westerns usually end with the lone hero riding away. But Hercules is about a kid who desperately wants to belong somewhere. If he rides off alone, he never gets the thing he was looking for. That's why we changed the ending. The classic Western ending would have broken the whole story.
The lesson
Genre has rules, and sometimes the story needs you to break them. Know which rule your hero needs to break.
New episodes drop on YouTube first. Subscribe to Mr. Bray Labs so you never miss one.
